The Pardon with a Price Tag

Published September 23, 2026
brown cross on brown rock during daytime

The other day, Ric and I were talking about a question raised in Jeremiah Johnston’s The Jesus Discoveries: What is the difference between a presidential commutation and a pardon? Johnston describes asking a federal judge to explain the distinction.

The judge replied, “When a president commutes a sentence, the punishment is reduced or ended, but the crime still stands. The crime still remains on the record, none of the individual’s civil rights are restored. It’s merciful, yes, but not full forgiveness.

When someone receives a presidential pardon it’s as if the crime never happened. In the eyes of the state the slate is wiped clean. All rights are restored – voting rights, travel rights, gun ownership rights, the right to hold public office. It’s not a reduction; it’s a full legal erasure. Not because the person didn’t commit the crime, but because the grace of the grantor made it so.

Presidents have had this power since 1789 when the constitution came into effect. I can think of recent years where presidents of both parties gave presidential pardons to people I personally didn’t think deserved it.

The misuse of such power for personal or political gain can feel deeply wrong. Yet the contrast also points me toward something greater: what God has done for us.

Romans 8:1-4

“So now there is no condemnation for those who belong to Christ Jesus….. The Law of Moses was unable to save us because of the weakness of our sinful nature. So, God did what the Law could not do. He sent his own son in a body, like the bodies we sinners have and, in that body, God declared an end to sin’s control over us by giving his son as a sacrifice for our sins. He did this so that the just requirement of the law would be fully satisfied for us who no longer follow our sinful nature but instead follow the Spirit.”

A president may exercise this power justly or for political gain, but no president has stepped down, taken the guilty person’s place, and paid the penalty on that person’s behalf. A presidential pardon may release someone who committed a grievous crime without requiring that person to bear the full punishment. 

Frustrating, yes! And I grumble and cast judgment on the obviously political act, then I’m humbled when I remember that I, too, will never have to pay the price for my own sins. 

God stepped down and paid the price for my sin and it’s as if they never happened. Forgiven. Redeemed. Restored. By Grace of the Grantor.

Thank you Lord!